On The Treasure Coast
Historic Downtown Stuart near the St. Lucie River
Back to Stuart dining

Stuart, Florida

Best Pizza in Stuart

Ask ten locals where to find the best pizza in Stuart and you will probably get ten different answers. That is usually a good sign. Stuart's pizza scene has more range than many towns its size, with brick-oven pies, coal-fired crust, classic New York-style pizza, and true wood-oven Neapolitan all in the mix.

7 min read

How to choose

The most useful answer is that there is no single best pizza in Stuart unless you define the style first. For most visitors, Carmela's Brick Oven Pizza is the best all-around starting point. For Neapolitan-style wood-oven pizza, go to Piatto Divino. For a classic New York-style pie, start with Brooklyn Joe's or Salerno. For a downtown sit-down meal, Luna Italian Cuisine is the strongest blend of location, menu range, and long-running local presence.

Stay current

Get Stuart food picks every week.

Use this guide for the durable shortlist. Use the newsletter for new openings, weekend plans, and the places locals are talking about now.

1

Carmela's Brick Oven Pizza and Wine Bar

If you want one recommendation that works for the widest range of people, Carmela's is it. It has the strongest all-around case in Stuart because the pizza is central to the identity, not an afterthought, and the restaurant balances casual comfort with enough polish for a real night out.

  • Best overall starting point for most readers.
  • Known for brick-oven pizza and a strong grandma pie lineup, especially the Grandma Margarita.
  • Best fit: casual pizza night, date night with wine, or dependable dinner for out-of-town guests.
Source
2

Piatto Divino

Piatto Divino is the clearest choice for diners who care about oven style and technique. If your pizza hierarchy starts with wood fire, blistered crust, and Neapolitan influence, this is where to begin.

  • Best Neapolitan-style pizza pick in Stuart.
  • Built around a traditional Neapolitan wood oven with Sicilian, Neapolitan, and Sardinian influences.
  • Best fit: food-forward pizza nights where the crust and bake matter most.
Source
3

Luna Italian Cuisine

Luna wins on location, range, and longevity. It is one of the easiest pizza recommendations when your evening already revolves around Historic Downtown Stuart and your group wants more than one style on the table.

  • Best downtown pizza dinner in Stuart.
  • Offers Margherita, White Pizza, Sicilian, Grandma's Pizza, and a cauliflower crust option.
  • Best fit: downtown sit-down dinner with menu flexibility for mixed groups.
Source
4

Brooklyn Joe's Pizza

Brooklyn Joe's looks like the strongest neighborhood pizzeria play in Stuart. This is the one to remember when what you really want is a straightforward New York-style pie and not a full Italian dining-room experience.

  • Best classic neighborhood New York-style pie.
  • Built around Brooklyn-style pizza and specialty pies.
  • Best fit: foldable weeknight pizza, pickup, delivery, and order-and-go meals.
Source
5

Salerno Pizza

Salerno is the value-minded New York-style option in Stuart. It makes the shortlist because it keeps the brief direct: thin-crust round pies, classic toppings, and pricing that can make it the smartest budget move in town.

  • Best value New York-style pizza pick.
  • Roots go back to 1980 with owners from Long Island and Staten Island.
  • Often advertises a Monday and Tuesday 16-inch cheese pizza special, though deals can change.
Source
6

Uncle Giuseppe's Lil Bit A Brooklyn

Uncle Giuseppe's is the right fit when your group wants pizza, but not only pizza. It brings broader Italian-restaurant energy while still giving you serious pizza variety.

  • Best for Sicilian-leaning variety and a bigger Italian menu.
  • Menu includes Meat Lovers, Bianca, Primavera, Grandma, Margherita, and Sicilian deep dish options.
  • Best fit: family-style dinner where some people want a broader Italian menu.
Source
7

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Anthony's is the outlier because it is a regional chain, but the coal-fired style is distinct enough that it still deserves a place. If you like a thinner, crisper, more char-driven pie, this is the style-specific pick.

  • Best coal-fired crust option in Stuart.
  • Coal-fired pizzas baked at 900 degrees with a firmer, roasty finish.
  • Best fit: diners who specifically want coal-fired pizza rather than New York or Neapolitan.
Source

The best pizza in Stuart, by craving

A faster shortlist.

  • Best overall: Carmela's Brick Oven Pizza
  • Best Neapolitan-style pizza: Piatto Divino
  • Best downtown pizza dinner: Luna Italian Cuisine
  • Best classic neighborhood New York-style pie: Brooklyn Joe's Pizza
  • Best value New York-style pizza: Salerno Pizza
  • Best for Sicilian-style variety and a bigger Italian menu: Uncle Giuseppe's Lil Bit A Brooklyn
  • Best coal-fired option: Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Final verdict

For a single headline answer, Carmela's Brick Oven Pizza is the best pizza in Stuart for most people. It has the right mix of longevity, pizza identity, strong signature pies, and broad public approval. But the style-specific answers matter more: Piatto Divino for wood-oven Neapolitan, Luna for downtown dining, Brooklyn Joe's for neighborhood New York-style, Salerno for value, Uncle Giuseppe's for broader family-style Italian, and Anthony's for coal-fired crust.

Sources

Related Stuart guides

Read these next if you are narrowing the same decision.

These guides cover the next questions readers usually ask after this one, so you can move from a broad answer to a more specific Stuart call without starting over.

Dining

Best Breakfast Places in Stuart

A practical guide to the best breakfast places in Stuart, Florida, including downtown cafes, classic diners, beachside breakfast spots, Cuban coffee, and all-day breakfast options.

Read guide

Dining

Best Local Coffee Shops in Stuart

A practical guide to the best local coffee shops in Stuart, Florida, including roasters, waterfront cafes, brunch spots, drive-thru options, and downtown hangouts.

Read guide

Dining

Best Restaurants in Stuart

A practical guide to the best restaurants in Stuart, Florida, including downtown dinners, seafood, waterfront picks, brunch, and date-night spots.

Read guide